The Clanging Chimes of Doom – Bandaid Remade and Remixed

Reposting to get you in the holiday spirit…. The original post appeared on Nov 20, 2010…. Enjoy! 🙂

This is perhaps one of the most impactful and damaging songs in history. I heard it on the radio today and got pissed off like I do every time I hear it.

Apparently the image of Africa and Africans hasn’t changed much since 1984. Twenty years later comes Band Aid 2 — because every multi-celebrity charity pity song needs a remake…. Love the intro sound of a crying starving child and the astonished yet highly concerned British commentator.

I don’t even know where to start on the stereotypes and disservice that this song (and similar charity marketing and sensationalist journalism) has done to the image of Africa (the Continent) and Africans themselves. I’ve spent quite a bit of time in African countries and I could post photo after photo of rivers and rain there. And things growing.  I never heard any clanging chimes of doom while there. There are lots of people who are not looking out their windows onto “a world of dread and fear”. Many of my African friends won’t celebrate Christmas because they are Muslim, not because they are starving to death. And many others will celebrate Christmas, but not American or Euro style. Not everyone is sitting underneath the burning sun. Africa is not a giant desert. Can we please not show famine in Ethiopia and pretend it’s representative of the entire continent? There won’t be snow in Africa? So what? Gahhhhh!

Luckily there is the glory of social media to take the edge off the fury…. If you don’t like the original version, there are plenty of re-makes to be found on YouTube. I’m not sure whether to laugh or cry. Here is a selection of the, uh, finest. You be the judge on whether these are worse than the original…. Taking votes in the comments section.

Feed the World with Friends (I wish this were a joke) Version. Wow. Just wow. E for effort. C for caring. D for Do Gooders. But the singing makes me doubt the potential for quality in anything crowdsourced.

Bad 1980s Sponsorship Organization Commercial Photo Montage Version. The original didn’t have enough pictures of crying children and flies in the eyes so this kind person overlaid some of the best of the worst charity photos on to the video to encourage us to care.  (Commenter: So, there won’t be snow in Africa this year? And you say the only gift they’ll get is the gift of life? So, no shoveling, and no commercial holidays? Sign me up.)

Singing Cartoon Turkeys Version (aka PETA Version?)

Dance Aid – Do they know it’s Christmas (Rave Mix) Instrumental so you can dance at your Christmas Rave without feeling guilty because of the lyrics.

Winnipeg Tea Party Version? “Dedicated to the poor children of Winnipeg School Division 1. Children whose childhood is less happy because schools run by tyrants will not say the word Christmas….  Christmas… A holiday so terrible according to commies that it can’t be named….” Special appearance poster by the Folsom Street Fair (the grand daddy of all gay male leather events) whose attendees “mock your religion while demanding that you get rid of the word Christmas…” ends with “glad this baby (Jesus) wasn’t aborted… stop the ACLU”.

2006 College Version complete with a lot of bare midriffs and self absorbed cleavage and blowing hair and dramatic effects which turn into…. a drink infested Christmas party… which ends up in a teenage mums against war protest slash terror attack… and ends with… um. Well if you make it through to the end maybe you can tell me what the point was?

Chris Brown feat. T-Pain laid over Karaoke Instrumental Version (?!?!)  I’m still not sure which lyrics are more awful — these or the original…. this is as bad, maybe worse, than the homemade versions– hard to make it through til the end.

High School Christmas Concert Version with uh high quality filming. (comments section: 3 letters is all this will take. OMG. And 2 words: bloody awful)

1985 High School Talent Show Version. Has that Risky Business feel to it. As a child of the 1980s I’m digging the outfits:

Canadian Version with lots of Tim Horton promos in the background…. “In 1984 the top recording artists across Canada gathered to raise money from the famine in Africa… when the public viewed Canada’s version, the world decided it was best for Canada to just make a fincial (sic) donation instead.”

Hipsters in a Mansion Version (TV Allstars) (“Bless ’em, they seem to think the clanging chimes of doom are something to be cheery about.”)

People in a Toystore with Tambourine and Ukelele Version? Commenter: “Sick! Sick and WRONG! I LOVE IT! My favorite lines: “There won’t be snow in Africa this christmas” (nor in LA, nor Hawaii…???) and “Thank God it’s THEM instead of You” ??? and “Here’s to them underneath that burning sun” – the stupidest lyrics ever !! YOU GUYS ROCK”

Status Quo Video Vault Version (anyone else love and remember The Young Ones? “All the homos in the place goin’ mental now….” “HomeOwners you mean, don’t you….”)

The Clanging Chimes of Doom are Back and Better than Ever Version. Voice and video don’t sync. There’s a dude singing in a shower. There’s a fake adopted black baby. Make it stop.

I’m happy that at least some musicians in the 80s were on the ball.  High 5 to Chumbawamba.

Feed the WorldPictures of Starving People“In 1986, the anarchist band Chumbawamba released the album Pictures of Starving Children Sell Records, as well as an EP entitled “We Are the World”, jointly recorded with US band A State of Mind, both of which were intended as anti-capitalist critiques of the Band Aid/Live Aid phenomenon. They argued that the record was primarily a cosmetic spectacle, designed to draw attention away from the real political causes of world hunger.”


Update Nov 29, 2010: And hey, it seems like Bob Geldof would totally agree with me on this post! I’m starting to gain a little respect for him. According to this Nov 29, 2010, article in the Daily Mail. Geldof, who penned the song 26 years ago together with Midge Ure, says: “I am responsible for two of the worst songs in history. One is Do They Know It’s Christmas? and the other one is We Are The World. Any day soon, I will go to the supermarket, head to the meat counter and it will be playing. Every ****ing Christmas….” The former Boomtown Rats frontman, 59, added: “Sometimes I think that’s wild because I wrote it. Or else I am thinking how much I want them to stop because they are doing it really badly.”


About Shotgun Shack

INGO worker hailing from the crossroads of America, and so far from home in so many ways. I blog about life and the depths and ironies of INGO work. View all posts by Shotgun Shack

14 responses to “The Clanging Chimes of Doom – Bandaid Remade and Remixed

  • j.


    I think you missed a song by Southpark? Maybe I’m getting my Christmas snarcasm mixed up…

  • Tom

    Wow, how did you manage to watch all of those videos? I could only handle a few seconds at a time.

    My choice is the turkey one. Runner up is the one with the young kids who have a Christmas party and weird news interruptions. Great finds.

  • Linda Raftree

    Woah, getting through some of those was a serious strain on my Sunday morning cognitive surplus!

    I’m going with Chris Brown/T-Pain as the worst but I think it’s safe to say that’s in a category of simply bad music all on its own.

    For worst actual Bandaid remake, I’m going with the first one – Feed the World with Friends. Second place – I agree with Tom – the 2006 college remake.

    And now I think I’m going to go find some old Chumbawamba for my music collection!

  • Tim Ogden

    In the college version, the change the lyric to: There won’t be snow in “Kyr-just-tan”…perhaps they meant Chechnya or Dagestan? Maybe prescient about the war in Georgia?

    Or was there a war and famine in Kyrgyz that I missed?

  • Carol

    Awesome post. Love it. I think I may have to vote for the turkeys too, if only for the element of surreality. Was, I admit, unable to watch all in their entirety. Not if I want to eat my lunch without puking.

  • Joe Turner

    Guess how many of those videos I watched. Go on.

    None, zero, zilch. I’d rather put my hand in a food blender.

    And the tragic thing is that these idiots think they are actually doing something, anything even vaguely helpful.

  • terence

    Good post but…This is perhaps one of the most impactful and damaging songs in history.

    Do you really think Africa’s post Band Aid history would have been at all different if the song had been better informed?

    FWIW I think that: (1) the song was just one drop in relatively large bucket of images emanating from Africa whenever people turn on the news and (2) the real determinants of the future of African countries lie within those countries themselves.

    If Bob the builder or Terence the teenage Duran Duran fan (sad but true in my case) and our ilk ended up somewhat misinformed by the song that’s a pity but I suspect that this has had absolutely zero impact on the recent history of Africa.

    • Shotgun Shack

      From one D2 fan to another… I ultimately agree with your point #2. But if you believe that ‘aid’ and the way it’s distributed have some kind of impact (yes I know that aid is just one part of financial flows, and that in many places ‘aid’ has very little impact on real people’s lives), and if you believe that the belief systems of the public impact on how aid is given, spent and distributed, then yes it does matter. This study “The Live Aid Legacy” sheds some light on why and how. I think it has some good points.
      You’re right- Band Aid was just one part of a whole slew of this kind of marketing (which unfortunately continues via many aid agencies). I guess I’m holding Band Aid up as the poster child of all of them.

  • terence

    Thanks for the link – I’ll have a read.

  • Gina

    Hey, I do not speak english very well, because I am mexican. But it seems to me that you did a really good job serching and explaining everything. My country is full of contrast, so every time I heard about “poor africans”, it seems to me they are talking about a lot of people in my county. Thanks for giving me another vision of Africa.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: